Opposition Leader Manasseh Sogavare disputes the Government’s Orbis claims and raises questions over the Attorney-General’s conduct.
The Leader of the Official Opposition, Manasseh Sogavare MP, has strongly rejected the Government’s 17 November 2026 statement on the Orbis claim, HCSI Civil Case No. 600 of 2025, describing it as a diversionary response that seeks to shift public attention away from the central and unresolved issue of the Attorney-General’s alleged conflict of interest in the Lever Solomons settlement.
“The Government has not answered a single question about the Attorney-General, Mr Gabriel Suri. Instead it has turned to a different case, a rumour and attacks on people who no longer hold office,” Sogavare said.
The matter is before the courts
On the Orbis claim, the Government’s own statement says the Attorney-General is pursuing the case in the Court of Appeal. If so, the questions it raises is whether the State was bound, how much is owed and why the judgment was entered. These are the very questions the Court of Appeal will decide.
The Attorney-General is the lawyer for the State in that appeal. It is not proper for a party to live proceedings to argue its case through Government press releases and to invite public judgment on people who are not parties and cannot answer in court. The sub judice rule exists to protect the court’s process, not to be set aside when it is politically convenient.
The Official Opposition will not comment on the merits of the appeal. The legal advice John Muria (Jnr) gave as Attorney-General belongs to the State and is privileged; it is not for publish and it should not be selectively described by others. What follows is confined to documents already on the public court file.
The late Mr Robson Djokovic
The GREAT Government repeats “reports” that the late Mr Robson Djokovic spoke of a SBD9 million commission. Mr Djokovic has passed away. He cannot confirm or deny what is attributed to him and he cannot be asked who he spoke to, when, or what he meant. No document, date or witness is offered.
A claim that rests on the reported words of a man who can no longer answer is not evidence. It is a rumour and it is unfair to his family. Mr Djokovic cannot speak for himself and the statement tries to defame a person who has passed away and will never defend himself or sue for defamation to clear his name.
The Official Opposition is aware of NO commission being proposed or paid to anyone. The allegation is false.
The statement does not say who wrote it. But it speaks of the Attorney-General’s appeal and of a case only he and his Chambers conduct. If the Attorney-General is responsible for it, or approved it, he faces a serious ethical problem.
- He is counsel for the State in a live appeal. A lawyer in pending proceedings must not argue the case in the media or say things that may prejudice the court’s decision. The Attorney-General, as the senior officer of the court, is held to the highest standard.
- He is the State’s principal legal adviser on the sub-judice rule and on defamation. If the statement prompts a defamation claim, it is his own Chambers that would have to defend the Government over words he may have written.
- On 1 July 2026 the High Court criticised the State for making serious allegations that were not made good and said such allegations should not be made without clear material. Repeating an unproven allegation of a commission, this time in public, is the same mistake.
- He chairs the disciplinary committee under the Legal Practitioners Act. If a complaint is made about this statement, he cannot sit in judgment of his own conduct.
- He acted for Lever Solomons Limited against the State and Lever Solomons told the High Court it shares a common interest with the State in this very case. An Attorney-General with that history should be stepping back from this matter, not leading a public campaign about it.
The Attorney-General should say plainly whether he wrote or approved this statement.
The amount comes from the claim, and leaves no room for a commission
The figure of AUD26.3 million is simply the Deed Fund of SBD140 million converted into Australian dollars. The Claim filed on 28 November 2025 sets out exactly where every dollar of that fund was to go. These are the claimants’ own figures, as at the end of 2025 (paragraph 48 of the Claim):
| Payment out of the Deed Fund | AUD |
| Secured creditor (Mr Wong), including interest, costs and the receiver’s fees | 12,457,899.50 |
| Administrators’ fees and costs – both companies | 3,492,913.00 |
| Liquidators’ fees and costs – both companies, including estimated future costs | 2,575,523.00 |
| Unsecured creditors of the two companies | 493,415.00 |
| Unsecured creditors of the van Vlymen bankrupt estates | 1,714,701.00 |
| Deferred creditors of the two companies | 4,428,094.00 |
| Total to be paid out | 25,162,545.50 |
The claim puts the total at about SBD136.75 million, leaving a surplus of about SBD3.25 million in the SBD140 million fund. Under the agreed terms, any surplus was to be returned to the Government and any shortfall was to be met by reducing payments to creditors, starting with the deferred creditors (paragraphs 31 and 35).
Three things follow.
(a) There is no line for a commission. Every dollar is allocated to a named class of creditor or to insolvency fees and the balance goes back to the State.
(b) The fund was to be paid into a separate trust account held by the Australian liquidators, who are officers answerable to the Australian courts and paid out only to those creditors. There was no mechanism by which a commission could be paid to anyone in Solomon Islands.
(c) No money was ever paid. The claim itself records that the bond issue never went ahead and the Deed Fund was never created (paragraph 46). Not one dollar left the Consolidated Fund. Nothing could have been paid out of a fund that does not exist.
As for the “increase” from AUD15.67 million, the Government has the 2022 administrators’ report and can check this for itself. The Claim’s figure includes items that the 2022 figure, as quoted, does not appear to cover: the creditors of the van Vlymen bankrupt estates and the deferred creditors, together about AUD6.14 million. It also includes interest and fees that kept growing while the matter was not completed – the secured debt alone rose from AUD11.63 million in February 2024 to AUD12.46 million by the end of 2025. That is the cost of delay, not of a commission. And in return for the fund, the State was to take control of the Russell Islands and Lever Solomons estates.
This was, and is, a matter for the Ministry of Finance and Treasury
The claim was brought against the Attorney-General as representative of the Government and the Minister of Finance and Treasury. Under the arrangement, the Minister of Finance (or a nominee) was to be the party taking over the companies, and the Minister was authorised to proceed with the bond issue. The decisions, the funding and the instructions all sat with the Ministry.
The Attorney-General acts on instructions, advices and does not make decisions, amongst other things, including but not limited to settlement. Chambers cannot make up a defence; a defence must be based on facts and evidence from the client ministry. The High Court’s ruling of 1 July 2026 records that Chambers asked the Permanent Secretary of Finance for instructions in December 2025, again on 19 December 2025, on 25 February 2026, on 31 March 2026, the day the defence was due and on 23 April 2026. The Ministry did not respond. The Court accepted that those requests were made and said that nothing in its reasons should be read as criticism of counsel.
The Court also noted that no sworn statement was ever filed by the Permanent Secretary or any officer of the Ministry to explain the silence. That remained so even after the change of Attorney-General, when the application to set aside the judgment was brought in June 2026. That application failed, with costs against the State on an indemnity basis.
If the Government wants to know why the State was left undefended, it should start by asking the Ministry of Finance and Treasury why it did not answer its own lawyers.
The Official Opposition will answer questions in the proper forum but will not try a case in the newspapers that the Attorney-General himself says is before the Court of Appeal. The Opposition will not allow a false allegation, resting on the reported words of a man who has died, to stand unanswered
Finally, the Government should not try to divert attention from the Attorney-General’s conflict of interest. It should address it. The questions remain unanswered: how can the lawyer who initially prepared, signed and filed Lever Solomons Limited’s claim against the State in 2016 sign, as Attorney-General, the order that settles that same case and commits the State to pay his former client SBD64.68 million? Did he declare his interest and why was the matter not handed to the Solicitor-General or independent counsel?
Instead of answering, the Government has turned to a different case, an unproven rumour and attacks on people who no longer hold office. That is an attempt to divert from and cover up, the Attorney-General’s conflict of interest. The public will not be distracted. The Government should answer the questions about the Attorney-General.
SOURCE// OPPOSITION PRESS RELEASE















